Comparison · checked November 2026
Morningstar Portfolio X-Ray alternatives: MEDGE vs Morningstar
Morningstar Investor is a research subscription with portfolio tools: X-Ray looks through your funds to show asset classes, sectors, regions, fees and overlap, next to Morningstar’s ratings and analyst research. MEDGE looks at the same portfolio from another angle: how it behaved on its full price history, why, and what a shock you define would do to it.
Published by MEDGE Capital. Morningstar details from its public pages, checked in November 2026: Morningstar portfolio tools · Portfolio X-Ray help · Linking accounts · Portfolio Risk Score. Prices are list prices for one user, before tax; check with the vendor before you buy.
| Morningstar | MEDGE | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Research subscription (ratings, analyst research, screeners) with portfolio tools: Portfolio, X-Ray, Stock Intersection | Portfolio analytics: backtests, attribution, regimes, stress scenarios and optimization |
| Price | Morningstar Investor $249 a year or $34.95 a month, with a 7-day trial; Morningstar says there is no free tier for Investor | Free plan with no time limit; Essential €14.99, Plus €39.99, Pro €59.99, Advisor €159 a month, two months free with yearly billing |
| Look-through | Asset class, stock sector, world regions, style boxes, fees and expenses, overlap between funds and stocks | Exposure measured from prices: beta and correlation to markets, sectors and factors, plus the portfolio’s own behaviour |
| Risk | Morningstar Portfolio Risk Score, a forward-looking number from Morningstar’s risk model | Volatility, drawdowns, Sharpe and correlation on every plan; Sortino, Calmar, VaR and CVaR from Essential; attribution per holding |
| Backtest | Not among the stated portfolio tools | Full price history of each holding, five rebalancing policies with costs, Monte Carlo, bear, neutral and bull regimes |
| Stress scenarios | Not among the stated portfolio tools | Stress Lab (from Essential): 11 ready scenarios or your own shocks on 45 benchmarks, propagated to every holding |
| How holdings get in | Manual entry, import, or linked accounts (linked accounts show balance and allocation, not cost basis) | Tickers and weights; no broker connection needed |
| Instruments | US stocks, funds and ETFs | US and European listings, UCITS ETFs included, each in its own trading currency |
Morningstar fits if…
- you want Morningstar’s ratings, analyst research and fair-value estimates next to your portfolio;
- you hold several US funds and want to see their overlap and total fees.
MEDGE fits if…
- you want to see how the mix behaved through past crises and in bear and bull markets;
- you want to test a shock you define on your own holdings;
- you hold European listings or UCITS ETFs, or want a free plan.
Frequently asked questions
- What is a good alternative to Morningstar Portfolio X-Ray?
- For fund look-through and Morningstar’s own research, X-Ray inside Morningstar Investor is the reference. For backtests, attribution per holding, regimes, Monte Carlo and custom stress scenarios, MEDGE covers a different part of the job, with a free plan and US and European listings.
- Is there a free alternative to Morningstar Investor?
- MEDGE has a free plan with no time limit that includes the backtesting lab, attribution, regimes, Monte Carlo and optimization. It does not include Morningstar’s ratings or analyst research.
- Does MEDGE show fund overlap like X-Ray?
- Not in the same way. X-Ray reads each fund’s holdings to show overlap and sectors. MEDGE measures how each holding actually moves with the others and with markets, which shows when two different funds behave alike.
Other comparisons
- PortfoliosLab alternatives
- Curvo alternatives
- Guardfolio alternatives
- Portfolio Performance alternatives
- Sharesight alternatives
- Empower alternatives
- Ghostfolio alternatives
- Snowball Analytics alternatives
- Stock Rover alternatives
- IBKR Risk Navigator alternatives
- MEDGE vs testfolio
- Portfolio Visualizer alternatives
- Best portfolio analytics tools
Bring your holdings. See where the risk sits.
Free plan with no time limit, no brokerage connection. Not investment advice.
Start free