Skip to content

Ultimate Buy and Hold Portfolio: backtest, returns and drawdowns

Ultimate Buy and Hold Portfolio: Sixty percent split equally across ten equity asset classes, forty percent in government bonds.

Data updated November 2026

Created by: Paul Merriman

Ultimate Buy and Hold Portfolio allocation

Asset classETF used in the backtestWeight
S&P 500IVV6%
US large-cap valueIVE6%
US small capsIJR6%
US small-cap valueIJS6%
US real estate (REITs)IYR6%
International large capsEFA6%
International large-cap valueEFV6%
International small capsSCZ6%
International small caps, dividend-weightedDLS6%
Emerging-market stocksEEM6%
Intermediate US TreasuriesIEF20%
Short-term US TreasuriesSHY12%
Inflation-protected Treasuries (TIPS)TIP8%
  • Stocks 60.0%
  • Bonds 40%

From November 2011 to November 2026 the Ultimate Buy and Hold Portfolio returned 6.7% a year on average, with annual volatility of 9.5%. Its deepest fall was 21.0%, from January 2020 to March 2020, recovered in about 10 months.

Its best year was 2019 (+17.1%) and its worst 2022 (−13.8%).

Over the same period 100% US stocks returned 14.1% a year with a maximum fall of 35.0%.

Key figures

Annual return (CAGR)
+6.7%
Annual volatility
9.5%
Maximum drawdown
−21.0%
Recovery time
10 months
Sharpe
0.57
Sortino
0.79
Worst year
2022: −13.8%
Positive years
11/14

Ultimate Buy and Hold Portfolio: growth of $10,000

$20,000$40,000$60,000201220172022
Ultimate Buy and Hold Portfolio60/40 Portfolio100% Stocks

Ultimate Buy and Hold Portfolio drawdowns

-20%-10%0%201220172022

Ultimate Buy and Hold Portfolio returns by calendar year

YearUltimate Buy and Hold Portfolio60/40 Portfolio100% Stocks
2026(partial)+7.6%+6.7%+11.2%
2025+16.0%+13.0%+17.0%
2024+5.1%+14.8%+23.8%
2023+11.5%+17.9%+26.1%
2022−13.8%−16.9%−19.5%
2021+11.1%+14.6%+25.7%
2020+6.8%+15.4%+20.7%
2019+17.1%+21.9%+30.7%
2018−7.0%−3.1%−5.3%
2017+13.9%+14.2%+21.4%
2016+7.8%+8.3%+12.1%
2015−0.8%+0.2%−0.1%
2014+4.1%+9.7%+12.2%
2013+12.4%+18.2%+31.8%
2012+12.4%+10.4%+14.7%
2011(partial)+0.7%+1.3%+1.5%

History

Created by
Paul Merriman
Who
Founder of the Merriman Financial Education Foundation
Year
2000s
Source
Paul Merriman’s articles and books (paulmerriman.com)
Funds in the backtest
13

Paul Merriman, a former investment adviser who now runs a non-profit foundation for financial education, designed the Ultimate Buy and Hold to show how much a portfolio could change by adding asset classes to the S&P 500. The equity part is split equally across ten classes: US and international large, large value, small and small value, plus US real estate and emerging markets.

The classic version holds 60% in these equity funds and 40% in government bonds: intermediate Treasuries, short-term Treasuries and inflation-protected Treasuries. Merriman’s articles compare it with the S&P 500 year by year over several decades.

Strengths and weaknesses

Strengths

  • Ten equity asset classes: very wide diversification
  • Deliberate tilt to value and small companies
  • Bond side in government bonds only

Weaknesses

  • Thirteen funds
  • The tilts lagged the S&P 500 for long stretches, as in the 2010s
  • Complex to replicate outside the US

International small-cap value is represented by an international small-cap dividend ETF (DLS), the closest US-listed fund with a long history.

How it works

Add value, small-cap, international and real-estate stocks to the S&P 500 in equal parts, and hold only government bonds on the safe side.

Backtest with total-return ETF prices (dividends reinvested), rebalanced to target weights on the first trading day of each year. Where a Vanguard fund has a short price history in our data, an iShares fund on the same market is used (for example ITOT for VTI, IVV for VOO). No fees, taxes or currency effects; first and last years are partial. Past results do not predict future returns.

Ultimate Buy and Hold Portfolio: questions

Who created the Ultimate Buy and Hold Portfolio?

Paul Merriman (founder of the Merriman Financial Education Foundation), 2000s. Source: Paul Merriman’s articles and books (paulmerriman.com).

What is the Ultimate Buy and Hold Portfolio?

Sixty percent split equally across ten equity asset classes, forty percent in government bonds. Allocation: 6% s&p 500, 6% us large-cap value, 6% us small caps, 6% us small-cap value, 6% us real estate (reits), 6% international large caps, 6% international large-cap value, 6% international small caps, 6% international small caps, dividend-weighted, 6% emerging-market stocks, 20% intermediate us treasuries, 12% short-term us treasuries, 8% inflation-protected treasuries (tips). Created by: Paul Merriman.

What is the Ultimate Buy and Hold Portfolio return?

In the backtest from November 2011 to November 2026 it returned 6.7% a year on average, with a maximum drawdown of 21.0%. US dollars, before fees and taxes.

How often should it be rebalanced?

The backtest rebalances once a year back to the target weights. Rebalancing more often changes little and adds costs; some investors rebalance only when a weight drifts beyond a threshold.

What was the worst drawdown of the Ultimate Buy and Hold Portfolio?

21.0%, from January 2020 to March 2020; it took about 10 months to get back to the previous high.

Other lazy portfolios

Source: MarketStack end-of-day prices. Historical and educational content: not a forecast and not investment advice. MEDGE Capital does not recommend buying or selling any instrument. Risk disclaimer.